Photo Comparison - vote

Below are two images I took recently of the same location, the water falls in Clinton, New Jersey at sunrise. It was a chilly autumn morning so you can see the fog rising from the water while the sun is starting to touch the trees above. I am wondering which you prefer, the vertical shot or the horizontal shot? Feel free to let me know either by commenting here, sending me an email, or a comment on facebook. If you think they both suck, feel free to let me know that also. Feedback and criticism helps one grow and improve.
Thanks.